Q53, run 2026-11-04-2024-sonnet-query
Are Belir Mining SA and Rotam Group Inc in the same group?
Tests: Sources: the stale parent from RESEARCH is overruled by the RATINGS record.
Expected: same_group = no
sql run 1
No. The authoritative record E5062 sits in the Belir group, and only the duplicate E5168 shows a Rotam parent.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql run 2
No. Their roots are E5059 and E5086.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql run 3
No. E5062 sits under E5059, while E5086 is its own top entity.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+markdown run 1
No. RATINGS (which holds parent links) places E5062 under E5060 and then the Belir group (E5059); the RESEARCH link to E5086 is not used. E5087 is a separate group.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+markdown run 2
No. RATINGS holds the parent links, so Belir Mining sits under E5060 and E5059 (Belir Group). The RESEARCH record E5168 pointing to E5086 is overridden.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+markdown run 3
No. E5062 sits under E5059. The RESEARCH duplicate E5168 pointing to E5086 is overridden by RATINGS, which holds for parent links.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql run 1
(no answer found)
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql run 2
Yes. Belir Mining (E5062) shares an LEI with E5168, which I took to sit in the Rotam group; I did not verify that link.
JSON: {"same_group": "yes"}
Why: same_group: expected no, got yes
sparql run 3
Depends. BELIR MINING SA (E5168) sits under E5086, while E5062 sits under E5060.
JSON: {"same_group": "depends"}
Why: same_group: expected no, got depends
sparql+ontology run 1
No. E5062's RATINGS parent chain leads to E5059 (Belir Group), not Rotam.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 2
No. Belir Mining sits in the Belir Group (E5059) under the RATINGS parent links.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 3
No. The RATINGS parent link, which governs, puts Belir Mining under Belir Group (E5059) via E5060.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+executed run 1
No. E5062 sits under E5059 and E5086 is its own group.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+executed run 2
No. E5062 is in the Belir group (E5059) and E5086 is a separate top entity.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+executed run 3
No. E5062's ultimate parent is E5059, while Rotam Group Inc (E5086) is itself a top entity.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+axioms run 1
No. Belir Mining's ultimate parent is E5059; Rotam's is E5086.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+axioms run 2
(no answer found)
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+axioms run 3
No. Their ultimate parents are E5059 and E5086.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}