Q53, run 2026-11-05-1515-sonnet-query
Are Belir Mining SA and Rotam Group Inc in the same group?
Tests: Sources: the stale parent from RESEARCH is overruled by the RATINGS record.
Expected: same_group = no
sql run 1
No. E5062 sits under E5059 (Belir Group AG) and E5086 is a separate root.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql run 2
No. Belir Mining sits in the Belir Group (E5059) and Rotam Group Inc is its own root.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql run 3
No. E5062 sits under E5059 (Belir Group AG), and E5086 is a separate root.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql run 4
No. E5062 sits under E5059 and E5086 is its own root.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql run 5
No. Belir Mining's top parent is E5059 (Belir Group) and Rotam's is E5086.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+markdown run 1
No. The RATINGS parent link puts E5062 under E5059 (via E5060). The RESEARCH record E5168 pointing to Rotam does not override it.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+markdown run 2
No. Belir Mining (E5062) sits under E5059, a different tree from Rotam (E5086).
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+markdown run 3
No. E5168 is the RESEARCH duplicate of E5062 (same LEI), and RATINGS holds for parent links, so Belir Mining sits in the Belir group, not Rotam.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+markdown run 4
No. RATINGS holds for parent links, so E5062 sits in the E5059 group, while E5086 heads its own group. The RESEARCH record E5168 that points to E5086 is overridden.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+markdown run 5
No. Belir Mining's chain ends at E5059, and Rotam Group (E5086) is a different top entity.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql run 1
No. Belir Mining (E5062) sits under root E5059 and Rotam under E5086.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql run 2
No. Belir Mining's top parent is E5059 (Belir Group AG), not E5086.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql run 3
(no answer found)
JSON: {"same_group": null}
Why: same_group: expected no, got None
sparql run 4
No. Belir (E5062) sits under E5060/E5059, and E5086 is not among its ancestors.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql run 5
Depends. E5062 is in the Belir group, but the upper-case record E5168 "BELIR MINING SA" sits under the Rotam group.
JSON: {"same_group": "depends"}
Why: same_group: expected no, got depends
sparql+ontology run 1
(no answer found)
JSON: {"same_group": null}
Why: same_group: expected no, got None
sparql+ontology run 2
No. E5062 sits in the Belir group under E5059, and E5086 is a separate top entity.
**Q54–Q56, Q58–Q61.** I couldn't determine these within the query limit, so they are null in the JSON.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 3
No. E5062 sits under E5060 and E5059 (Belir Group AG).
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 4
No. Belir Mining's chain ends at Belir Group AG (E5059), while Rotam Group (E5086) is a separate top.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 5
No. E5062 goes up through E5060 to E5059, which has no parent in RATINGS, the system of record for parent links. A stray record linking E5059 to Rotam is overridden by that.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+executed run 1
No. E5062 belongs to the E5059 group.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+executed run 2
No. E5062 belongs to the E5059 group and E5086 is a separate top entity.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+executed run 3
No. E5062 sits under E5059 (Belir Group) and E5086 is a separate top entity.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+executed run 4
No. E5062 sits under E5059, while Rotam Group Inc (E5086) is a separate group top.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sql+executed run 5
No. E5062 sits under E5059 and E5086 is its own top.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+axioms run 1
No. E5062 sits under E5059, while Rotam's top is E5086.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+axioms run 2
No. E5062 belongs to the Belir group (E5059) and E5086 is Rotam's own top.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+axioms run 3
No. They have different ultimate parents (E5059 and E5086).
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}
sparql+axioms run 4
(no answer found)
JSON: {"same_group": null}
Why: same_group: expected no, got None
sparql+axioms run 5
No. E5062's ultimate parent is E5059, while E5086 is its own.
JSON: {"same_group": "no"}