Q22, run 2026-11-06-0519-sonnet-query
Which has more citations, W30 or W31 (counting both versions of each): in total, and within its publication year and the two years after?
Tests: Citation windows: the older work has had more time; over the same span the newer one leads.
Expected: more_in_total = W30 more_in_window = W31
sql run 1
W30 has more in total, with 18 against 15 for W31 and its preprint W42. W31 has more in its window, with 15 against 2 for W30.
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql run 2
W30 has more in total (18 against 13 for W31 plus its preprint W42). Within the publication year and the two years after, W31 has more (13 against 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql run 3
W30 has more in total (18 vs 13 for W31 and its version W42). W31 has more in the window (13 vs 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql run 4
W30 has more citations in total (18 vs 13). W31 has more within its publication year and the two years after (13 vs 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql run 5
In total, W30 has more (18 vs 13). In the publication year plus two years after, W31 has more (13 vs 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql+markdown run 1
W30 has more in total (16 against 11), and W31 has more within its window (11 against 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql+markdown run 2
More in total: W30 (16 against 11). More within the window: W31 (11 against 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql+markdown run 3
W31 has more in total (7 against 4) and more within its window (6 against 3).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W31", "more_in_window": "W31"}
Why: more_in_total: expected W30, got W31
sql+markdown run 4
In total W30 has more (16 against 11). Within its publication year and the two years after, W31 has more (11 against 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql+markdown run 5
In total W30 has more (16 against 11). Within the publication year and the two years after, W31 has more (11 against 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql+executed run 1
In total W30 has more (16 vs 11). Within the publication year and the two years after, W31 has more (11 vs 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql+executed run 2
W30 has more citations in total (16 vs 11). W31 has more within its publication year and the two years after (11 vs 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql+executed run 3
W30 has more in total (16 vs 11). W31 has more within its publication year and the two years after (11 vs 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql+executed run 4
More in total: W30 (16 vs 11). More in the window of its publication year plus two years: W31 (11 vs 1).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sql+executed run 5
W30 has more citations in total, 16 against 11. W31 has more within its publication year plus two years, 11 against 2.
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sparql run 1
W31, counting its preprint W42, has more citations in both cases. In total W31 has 13 against 18 for W30... that is wrong on that count: W30 has more in total (18 against 13). Within the publication year and the next two years W31 leads (13 against 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sparql run 2
W30 has more citations in total (18 against 13). W31 has more within its window (13 against 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sparql run 3
W30 has more in total (18 vs 13) and more in the window (18 vs 14).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W30"}
Why: more_in_window: expected W31, got W30
sparql run 4
I cannot answer this. The citation-window query failed and I had no rounds left to rerun it.
JSON: {"more_in_total": null, "more_in_window": null}
Why: more_in_total: expected W30, got None; more_in_window: expected W31, got None
sparql run 5
(no answer found)
JSON: {"more_in_total": null, "more_in_window": null}
Why: more_in_total: expected W30, got None; more_in_window: expected W31, got None
sparql+ontology run 1
W30 has more citations in total (16 against 11) and within the three-year window (16 against 12).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W30"}
Why: more_in_window: expected W31, got W30
sparql+ontology run 2
In total W30 has more (18 against 13). Within the window I could not see the citing years of the large-ID citers. W31 is the likely answer, because all its citers fall in 2023–2025, but this is unconfirmed.
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sparql+ontology run 3
In total, W30 has more (16 against 11). Within its publication year and the next two, W31 has more (11 against 2). W30 was published in 2019, W31 in 2023.
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sparql+ontology run 4
W30 has more citations in total (16 against 11). W31, counting W42, has more within its window (11 against 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}
sparql+ontology run 5
W30 has more in total (16 against 11). W31 has more within its window (11 against 2).
JSON: {"more_in_total": "W30", "more_in_window": "W31"}