Q48, run 2026-11-06-0206-haiku

← back to the run

Why is W70 not one of the University of Albury's research works, though its author lists the Tessel Laboratory?

Tests: Local rules: the last-listed affiliation, and affiliated institutes.

Expected: Tomasz Wierzba lists the Tessel Laboratory first and the Halloran Institute second; the house rule credits the last-listed one, Halloran. Halloran is an affiliated institute (AFF): its parent link is an agreement, so its works are not the University of Albury's.

❌ R1 csv run 1 graded by llm

The premise is wrong. W70 is credited to the University of Albury through the Tessel Laboratory (I04 → I03 → I02) and the Halloran Institute (I06 → I02).

Why: Rejects the premise and says W70 counts for Albury, contradicting the checklist (last-listed affiliation only, Halloran is an affiliated institute not a unit).

❌ R1 csv run 2 graded by llm

The premise is wrong. W70's author A08 is credited to I04 (Tessel Laboratory) and to I06, and both sit under I02, so W70 is a University of Albury work.



Q11–Q14, Q16, Q27–Q30, Q33, Q34, Q39 and Q47 are not yet computed. They need the Kesting (I07) and Rostval (I09) lists, the full S01 count, and the citation tallies, so I'll take them in the next batch. Counts marked as manual-scan estimates (Q6, Q9, Q10, Q15, Q21, Q35, Q36, Q45) should be re-checked against the CSVs before you rely on them.

Why: Rejects the premise; the key says only the last-listed affiliation counts, so W70 is credited to the Halloran Institute, an affiliated institute that doesn't roll up to Albury.

❌ R1 csv run 3 graded by llm

The premise is wrong. W70 is credited to I04 (Tessel, under the Albury Centre) and I06 (Halloran, a unit of the University of Albury), so it is one of the University of Albury's research works.

Why: Contradicts the checklist: it says Halloran is a unit of Albury and W70 counts, whereas the checklist says only the last affiliation counts and Halloran is an affiliated institute that does not roll up.

❌ R1 csv run 4 graded by llm

(no answer found)

Why: No answer given; meets none of the checklist points

❌ R1 csv run 5 graded by llm

The premise is false. W70's author A08 is listed at I04 (Tessel) and I06 (Halloran), and both roll up to I02 (University of Albury), so W70 is one of the University of Albury's research works.

Why: Rejects the premise and claims W70 counts; misses the last-listed-affiliation rule and that Halloran is an affiliated institute not rolling up to Albury.

❌ R3 csv+padding run 1 graded by llm

The premise is wrong. W70's author A08 is credited at I04 (Tessel Laboratory, under I03 and I02), so W70 is an Albury research work, and it is also credited at I06.

Why: Answer denies the premise and says W70 is an Albury work; checklist says it is credited only to Halloran Institute (last affiliation), an affiliated institute that doesn't roll up, so it is not Albury's.

❌ R3 csv+padding run 2 graded by llm

The premise is wrong. W70's author A08 is listed at I04 (Tessel Laboratory) and I06 (Halloran Institute), and both sit under the University of Albury (I02). So W70 is one of the University of Albury's works.

Why: Rejects the premise; the key says only the last-listed affiliation counts, so W70 is credited to the Halloran Institute, an affiliated institute that doesn't roll up to Albury.

❌ R3 csv+padding run 3 graded by llm

The premise is incorrect. W70 is credited to I04 (Tessel) and I06 (Halloran), both units of the University of Albury (I02), so it is one of Albury's works.

JSON: {"explanation": "Premise is incorrect: W70 is credited to I04 and I06, both units of I02."}

Why: Answer denies the premise and says W70 is Albury's; checklist says it is credited only to Halloran, an affiliated institute not rolling up to Albury.

❌ R3 csv+padding run 4 graded by llm

The premise is wrong. W70's author A08 lists I04 (Tessel, under I03 → I02) and I06 (Halloran, under I02), so W70 is credited to the University of Albury.

Why: Rejects the premise instead of saying only the last-listed affiliation counts (Halloran) and that Halloran is an affiliated institute that doesn't roll up to Albury.

❌ R3 csv+padding run 5 graded by llm

The premise is false. W70's author A08 is credited to Tessel Laboratory (I04) and to I06, and both sit under the University of Albury, so W70 is an Albury work.

Why: Says W70 is an Albury work and never mentions the last-listed-affiliation rule or the Halloran Institute being affiliated rather than a unit.

✅ R4 csv+markdown run 1 graded by llm

W70's last-listed affiliation is the Halloran Institute (I06), an affiliated institute. AFF institutes are never credited to their nominal parent or anything above it, so W70 is not credited to the University of Albury (I02). The Tessel Laboratory (I04) is only the earlier affiliation, which the house rule ignores.

**Remaining questions:** Q6, Q9–Q14, Q16–Q35, Q39, Q44, Q45 and Q47 still need working through. Q16 (S01 totals) and the institution-subtree counts (Q6, Q9–Q14) need a systematic pass over the authorships, so I'll take them next, starting with Q9.

❌ R4 csv+markdown run 2 graded by llm

(no answer found)

Why: No answer given; meets none of the checklist points

✅ R4 csv+markdown run 3 graded by llm

W70's author A08 lists the Tessel Laboratory (I04) first and the Halloran Institute (I06) last. Only the last-listed affiliation counts, and I06 is an affiliated institute, which is not a unit of the University of Albury.

✅ R4 csv+markdown run 4 graded by llm

A08 listed the Tessel Laboratory (I04) first and the Halloran Institute (I06) second on W70. Only the last-listed affiliation counts, which is I06, and I06 is an affiliated institute, not a unit of the University of Albury, so W70 is not credited to I02.

Remaining questions (Q6, Q7, Q9–Q36, Q38, Q39, Q42, Q44, Q45, Q47) need the next batch. The citation and fractional-count questions are the longest, so I will take them in smaller groups.

✅ R4 csv+markdown run 5 graded by llm

A08 lists Tessel (I04) first and Halloran (I06) second. Only the last-listed affiliation counts, so the work goes to I06, an affiliated institute that is not a unit of I02.

\* Counts marked with an asterisk came from a hand pass over the full authorship and citation files. They are likely right but may contain small slips.

❌ R5 csv+ontology run 1 graded by llm

(no answer found)

Why: No answer given; meets none of the checklist points

🟡 R5 csv+ontology run 2 graded by llm

W70 is not credited to the University of Albury because A08's last-listed affiliation on W70 is I06 (Halloran, an affiliated institute), not the Tessel Laboratory (I04). Only the last-listed affiliation is credited.

Why: Says only the last-listed affiliation counts and it is Halloran (I06), but omits that Halloran is an affiliated institute rather than a unit so its works don't roll up to Albury.

✅ R5 csv+ontology run 3 graded by llm

W70 lists Tessel (I04) at seq 1 and Halloran (I06) at seq 2. Per the house rule only the last-listed affiliation counts, and Halloran is an affiliated institute, not a unit of I02.

🟡 R5 csv+ontology run 4 graded by llm

W70's last-listed affiliation is I06 (seq 2), not the Tessel Laboratory I04 (seq 1). I06 is an affiliated institute, not a unit of I02, so the work is not credited to the University of Albury.

**Pending:** Q6, Q9–Q14, Q16, Q19–Q23, Q25, Q27–Q36, Q39, Q47. These need citation rollups, full-institution enumeration, or fractional counts. I'll work through them in the next pass.

Why: Correctly says last-listed affiliation (I06) counts and it is an affiliated institute not a unit of the University, but doesn't name it as the Halloran Institute (only I06) or explicitly credit W70 to it

✅ R5 csv+ontology run 5 graded by llm

W70's author A08 gave two affiliations: I04 (seq 1) and I06 (seq 2). The house rule credits only the last-listed one, I06, which is an affiliated institute and so not a unit of I02.

🟡 R10 executed run 1 graded by llm

W70 is credited to A08 at I06 (Halloran), not I04. The Tessel lab (I04) is credited only on W71. I06 counts only towards itself in institution_units, so W70 is not in the University of Albury family.

Why: Says W70 is credited to Halloran (I06) and that I06 doesn't roll up to Albury, but doesn't state that only the last-listed affiliation counts.

🟡 R10 executed run 2 graded by llm

W70's only credit is A08 at I06 (Halloran), not I04; the Tessel (I04) credits are on W71 and W72. Also, I06 counts only toward itself in institution_units, so W70 is outside Albury's units.

Why: Says Halloran (I06) is not a unit so it doesn't roll up to Albury, but doesn't state the last-listed-affiliation rule explicitly

🟡 R10 executed run 3 graded by llm

The premise is wrong. W70's only credit is A08 at I06 (Halloran), not I04 (Tessel); A08's Tessel credits are on W71 and W72. Halloran's parent in institutions.csv is I02, but institution_units counts I06 only towards itself, so its works do not count as Albury's.



Q47 and Q48 have no field specification in the JSON template, so they appear only in the text above. Counts were tallied by hand across the CSVs, so treat the larger tallies (Q9–Q11, Q16, Q21, Q36) as careful but not machine-verified.

Why: Gets Halloran credit and that it doesn't roll up to Albury, but never states the last-listed-affiliation rule and instead denies the Tessel premise.

🟡 R10 executed run 4 graded by llm

The premise is wrong. W70's only credit is A08 at I06 (Halloran Institute). No Tessel (I04) credit appears on W70.

Why: Says W70 is credited to the Halloran Institute, but gives no last-listed-affiliation rule and does not say the institute is affiliated rather than a unit, so its works don't roll up to Albury.

🟡 R10 executed run 5 graded by llm

W70 is credited only to I06 (Halloran Institute), via A08, not to the Tessel Laboratory (I04). I06 is not in I02's units, so W70 does not count towards the University of Albury.

Why: Says W70 is credited only to Halloran (I06) and that I06 is not one of I02's units, but never states the last-listed-affiliation rule or that Halloran is an affiliated institute.