Q5, run 2026-11-06-0808-sonnet-query
Is the M. Ellison who wrote W08 the same person as the Mara Ellison who wrote W01?
Tests: Identity: a name variant shared with a different person.
Expected: same = no
sql run 1
No. W08's M. Ellison is A04, whose ORCID differs from Mara's.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql run 2
No. W08 is by A04 (ORCID …8360), and W01 is by A01 (ORCID …6229).
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql run 3
No. W08's M. Ellison is A04, whose ORCID differs from A01's.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql run 4
No. W08's M. Ellison is A04, whose ORCID differs from Mara's.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql run 5
No. W08 is by A04 and W01 by A01; their ORCIDs differ.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql+markdown run 1
No. A04 (W08) has ORCID 0000-0004-8662-8360, which differs from Mara's.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql+markdown run 2
No. The M. Ellison on W08 is A04, with a different ORCID from Mara Ellison (A01).
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql+markdown run 3
No. The M. Ellison on W08 is A04, whose ORCID differs from A01's.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql+markdown run 4
No. W08's M. Ellison is A04, whose ORCID differs from A01's.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql+markdown run 5
No. A04 has a different ORCID from A01, so they are different people despite the similar name.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql+executed run 1
No. W08 is by A04 and W01 by A01, who are separate people with different ORCIDs, so the data gives no basis to merge them.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql+executed run 2
No. W08 is by A04 (I07) and W01 by A01 (I02), and the people table keeps them as separate people with different ORCIDs.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql+executed run 3
No. W08 is by A04 and W01 by A01, who have different ORCIDs and are separate people in `people`.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql+executed run 4
No. The M. Ellison of W08 is A04 (ORCID 0000-0004-8662-8360). Mara Ellison of W01 is A01, who has a different ORCID.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sql+executed run 5
No. W08 is by A04 and W01 by A01, who are separate people with different ORCIDs.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sparql run 1
No. W08's M. Ellison is A04 (ORCID 0000-0004-8662-8360), not A01.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sparql run 2
(no answer found)
Why: no structured answer
sparql run 3
No. W08 is by A04, whose ORCID differs from Mara Ellison's.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sparql run 4
No. W08 is by A04 (Kesting, a different ORCID), not by the Mara Ellison of W01.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sparql run 5
No. The W08 author is A04, whose ORCID differs from Mara's.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 1
No. W08's M. Ellison is A04, whose ORCID differs from Mara Ellison's.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 2
No. W08 is by A04 and W01 is by A01, and their ORCIDs differ.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 3
Depends. A02 ("M. Ellison") shares Mara's ORCID, but A04 ("M. Ellison") has a different ORCID, and W08 lists both A02 and A04.
JSON: {"same": "depends"}
Why: same: expected no, got depends
sparql+ontology run 4
No. W08 is by A04, whose ORCID differs from Mara's.
JSON: {"same": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 5
No. W08 is by A04 (ORCID …8360) and W01 by A01 (ORCID …6229).
JSON: {"same": "no"}