Q26, run 2026-11-06-0808-sonnet-query
Does W23 count towards Kesting University's research output?
Tests: Retractions: a retracted work is not research output.
Expected: counts = no
sql run 1
Yes. W23 is a research article that is flagged retracted; excluding retracted works would be a policy choice the data doesn't state.
JSON: {"counts": "yes"}
Why: counts: expected no, got yes
sql run 2
Yes. W23 is a retracted ART but still a research work, and the data gives no rule excluding retractions.
JSON: {"counts": "yes"}
Why: counts: expected no, got yes
sql run 3
Yes. W23 is an ART from I07 and its retraction flag does not remove it from the record, though a policy could exclude retracted works.
JSON: {"counts": "yes"}
Why: counts: expected no, got yes
sql run 4
Yes. The record is flagged retracted but is still an article, so I counted it. Whether retracted works should count is a policy choice the data doesn't settle.
JSON: {"counts": "yes"}
Why: counts: expected no, got yes
sql run 5
Yes. W23 is flagged retracted but is still an article, and nothing in the data excludes it.
JSON: {"counts": "yes"}
Why: counts: expected no, got yes
sql+markdown run 1
No. W23 is retracted.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sql+markdown run 2
No. W23 is retracted.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sql+markdown run 3
No. W23 is retracted.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sql+markdown run 4
No. W23 is retracted.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sql+markdown run 5
No. W23 is retracted, so it is not research output.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sql+executed run 1
No. W23 is retracted and not research output.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sql+executed run 2
No. W23 is retracted and its research_output is "no".
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sql+executed run 3
No. W23 is retracted and not research output.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sql+executed run 4
No. W23 is retracted and flagged research_output = no.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sql+executed run 5
No. W23 is retracted and is not research output.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sparql run 1
Yes, if retracted works are kept in counts. W23 is an article flagged retracted, and the data states no exclusion rule.
JSON: {"counts": "yes"}
Why: counts: expected no, got yes
sparql run 2
(no answer found)
Why: no structured answer
sparql run 3
Yes. W23 is flagged retracted but is still an article by an I07 author. The data does not say retractions are excluded.
JSON: {"counts": "yes"}
Why: counts: expected no, got yes
sparql run 4
Depends. W23 is an article, but it is flagged retracted, and the data doesn't say whether retracted works count.
JSON: {"counts": "depends"}
Why: counts: expected no, got depends
sparql run 5
No. W23 is retracted.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 1
No. W23 is retracted.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 2
No. W23 is retracted.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 3
No. W23 was shown as retracted (true) in the first clean result, so it is not research output.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 4
No. W23 is retracted.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
sparql+ontology run 5
No. W23 is retracted.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}