Q48, run 2026-11-04-2035-haiku
Why is W70 not one of the University of Albury's research works, though its author lists the Tessel Laboratory?
Tests: Local rules: the last-listed affiliation, and affiliated institutes.
Expected: Tomasz Wierzba lists the Tessel Laboratory first and the Halloran Institute second; the house rule credits the last-listed one, Halloran. Halloran is an affiliated institute (AFF): its parent link is an agreement, so its works are not the University of Albury's.
csv run 1
The premise is wrong. W70 is credited to I04 (a unit of I03 and I02) and to I06 (a child of I02), so it is one of the Albury units' research works and is counted in Q9.
Why: Rejects the premise, while the key says W70 is credited only to the last-listed affiliation (Halloran Institute), which is an affiliated institute that does not roll up to Albury.
csv run 2
The premise is false: W70 is counted in the University of Albury's output. **Reasoning:** The Tessel Laboratory (I04) sits under I03, which sits under I02 (University of Albury), and W70 is an ART record from 2023, so it is included in the 13 works in Q9.
Why: Rejects the premise and says W70 counts for Albury, whereas the key says it is credited to the Halloran Institute (last-listed affiliation), an affiliated institute that does not roll up to Albury
csv run 3
The premise is false. I04 sits under I03 and I02, so W70 is credited to the University of Albury through I04. I06 is also under I02, and W70 is included in the 13 works in Q9.
Why: Rejects the premise and credits W70 to the University of Albury, contradicting the key: only the last-listed affiliation counts (Halloran Institute), and as an affiliated institute rather than a unit it does not roll up to Albury.
csv run 4
The premise doesn't hold. W70 is credited to Albury through both I04 (Tessel, a unit of I03 and I02) and I06 (Halloran, a unit of I02), and it is an article, so it is one of Albury's research works (counted in Q9).
Why: Contradicts the checklist: it denies the premise and says W70 counts for Albury, whereas the key says only the last-listed affiliation counts and Halloran is an affiliated institute, not a unit.
csv run 5
The premise is false. W70 lists I04 (Tessel) and I06 (Halloran), and both sit under University of Albury (I04 → I03 → I02; I06 → I02). W70 is therefore one of Albury's 13 research works in Q9.
Why: Rejects the premise; the key says only the last-listed affiliation counts, so W70 goes to Halloran, an affiliated institute that doesn't roll up to Albury.
executed run 1
W70's only credit is A08 at I06 (Halloran), not at I04 (Tessel). I06 is not in the Albury units (institution_units lists I06 only under itself), so W70 does not count. Even though I04 is an Albury unit, the premise doesn't hold because that credit is not on W70.
Q47 and Q48 have no field in the schema, so they are not in the JSON block.
Why: Says W70 is credited only to Halloran (I06) and that I06 is not an Albury unit, but never states the rule that only the last-listed affiliation counts, and doesn't call Halloran an affiliated institute.
executed run 2
The premise does not hold in the data. W70's only credit is A08 at I06 (Halloran), not I04 (Tessel), and I06 counts only towards itself in institution_units, so it is not one of Albury's works.
Why: Says W70 is credited only to Halloran (I06) and that I06 counts only for itself, so it doesn't roll up to Albury; but it never says the last-listed affiliation rule explicitly, and it frames the premise as false rather than explaining that Halloran is an affiliated institute, not a unit.
executed run 3
W70's credit for A08 is I06 (Halloran), not I04 (Tessel). Tessel appears only on W71 and W72. Even on a Tessel credit, the premise would fail for another reason: I04 would count towards I02.
Why: Correctly says W70 is credited to Halloran (last-listed affiliation), but doesn't state that Halloran is an affiliated institute, not a unit, so its works don't roll up to Albury; its stated reason concerns Tessel counting towards I02.
executed run 4
The premise doesn't match the data. credits.csv records one institution per person per work, and A08 on W70 is credited to I06 (Halloran), not I04. A08 is credited to I04 on W71 and W72 instead. This is an interpretation: the JSON has no field for Q48.
Why: Identifies that W70 is credited to Halloran (I06) rather than Albury, but omits that Halloran is an affiliated institute, not a unit, so its works don't roll up to Albury; it also doesn't state the last-listed-affiliation rule.
executed run 5
The premise doesn't match the data. W70's author A08 is credited to I06 (Halloran), not the Tessel Laboratory (I04). Tessel appears only on W71 and W72, and I06 counts only towards itself in institution_units, so W70 is not an Albury work.
Why: Says W70 is credited to Halloran (I06) and that I06 counts only toward itself, but does not state the 'last-listed affiliation counts' rule and does not explicitly call Halloran an affiliated institute rather than a unit.