Q26, run 2026-11-04-2035-haiku
Does W23 count towards Kesting University's research output?
Tests: Retractions: a retracted work is not research output.
Expected: counts = no
csv run 1
Depends. W23 is an ART by I07 and is counted under the type rule, but it is flagged is_retracted=true and the data doesn't say whether retractions are excluded. Excluding it would drop Kesting to 8.
JSON: {"counts": "depends"}
Why: counts: expected no, got depends
csv run 2
Depends. **Reasoning:** W23 is an ART record credited to I07, but it is flagged is_retracted=true and the data does not state whether retracted works count as output.
JSON: {"counts": "depends"}
Why: counts: expected no, got depends
csv run 3
Depends. The data flags W23 as retracted and types it ART, but it does not say whether retracted works are excluded from output. Counts in Q11 and Q24 include it.
JSON: {"counts": "depends"}
Why: counts: expected no, got depends
csv run 4
Depends. W23 is an article by type but is flagged retracted, and the data has no rule for retracted works. It is counted in Q11, and that count falls to 8 if retracted works are excluded.
JSON: {"counts": "depends"}
Why: counts: expected no, got depends
csv run 5
Yes. W23 is an ART credited to I07 via A09. Its is_retracted flag does not change its type, though a policy excluding retracted works would remove it.
JSON: {"counts": "yes"}
Why: counts: expected no, got yes
executed run 1
No. W23 is retracted and its research_output is no.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
executed run 2
No. W23 is retracted and its research_output is "no".
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
executed run 3
No. W23 is retracted and not research output, so it does not count toward I07.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
executed run 4
No. W23 has research_output "no" because it is retracted.
JSON: {"counts": "no"}
executed run 5
No. W23 is retracted and marked research_output "no".
JSON: {"counts": "no"}