Q21, run 2026-11-05-2135-sonnet

← back to the run

Which entities had an issuer rating at some point but no longer had one on 1 October 2026?

Tests: Withdrawals: a withdrawn rating is no rating.

Expected: entities = ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320']

✅ R1 csv run 1 graded by code

35 entities. Each has a WD (withdrawal) as its latest action and no later rating action. E1279 is not listed because its LC rating (A1596) was never withdrawn.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

❌ R1 csv run 2 graded by code

36 entities, all of whose latest LTIDR action on or before 2026-10-01 is a withdrawal (WD). They are listed in the JSON; E1001 is carried by E1002's actions, E1021 by E1022's, E1138 by E1139's, and E1253 by E1254's.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1279", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

Why: entities: expected ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320'], got ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1279', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320']

❌ R1 csv run 3 graded by code

36 entities, listed in the JSON. E07 and 35 others had their ratings withdrawn (WD) before 2026-10-01.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1279", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

Why: entities: expected ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320'], got ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1279', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320']

✅ R1 csv run 4 graded by code

35 entities (listed in the JSON). Each was rated and then withdrawn by 2026-10-01.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

❌ R1 csv run 5 graded by code

36 entities. Each had an LTIDR rating but its latest action is a withdrawal (WD) on or before 2026-10-01. Entities withdrawn and later re-rated (E1115, E1158, E1303) are not included.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1279", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

Why: entities: expected ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320'], got ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1279', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320']

❌ R2 rdf run 1 graded by code

37 entities; see the JSON. These are entities whose last action is a withdrawal (WD). For E1106 and E1279 the withdrawal is tagged to one currency basis, but I treated it as covering the whole entity.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1002", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1106", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1254", "E1277", "E1279", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

Why: entities: expected ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320'], got ['E07', 'E1002', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1106', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1254', 'E1277', 'E1279', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320']

✅ R2 rdf run 2 graded by code

Thirty-five entities. These had a long-term IDR that was later withdrawn (WD) before 2026-10-01 with no rating after it. I left out E1106 and E1279, which still have another currency basis rated, and E1115, E1158 and E1303, whose rating dates conflict with their WD.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1002", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1254", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

❌ R2 rdf run 3 graded by code

37 entities, listed in the JSON. Each had a rating and its latest action by 2026-10-01 is a withdrawal. I used the canonical RATINGS IDs for E1001 (A1002 sits on duplicate E1002) and E1253 (A1540 sits on duplicate E1254).

JSON: {"entities": ["E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1106", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1279", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320", "E07"]}

Why: entities: expected ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320'], got ['E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1106', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1279', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320', 'E07']

✅ R2 rdf run 4 graded by code

35 entities (list in JSON). Their latest LTIDR action is a withdrawal (WD) dated before 1 Oct 2026. E1106 and E1279 are not listed because withdrawals applied to only one currency basis and the other basis remains.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1002", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1254", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R2 rdf run 5 graded by code

35 entities had a long-term rating that was later withdrawn, with no rating after that (IDs in the JSON).

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1002", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1254", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R6 rdf+ontology run 1 graded by code

35 entities. Their LTIDR was withdrawn with no later rating action and no remaining LC or FC rating on the other basis. RESEARCH twins are mapped to their RATINGS records (E1002→E1001, E1254→E1253).

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R6 rdf+ontology run 2 graded by code

The 35 entities whose latest issuer-rating action is a withdrawal, for example E07 (A19) and E1001 (A1002, recorded on E1002).

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R6 rdf+ontology run 3 graded by code

35 entities had their rating withdrawn before 1 October 2026 and had no later rating action, listed in the JSON. I excluded E1106, E1115, E1158, E1279 and E1303 because each still holds a rating on another basis or has a later rating action.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R6 rdf+ontology run 4 graded by code

Thirty-five entities had a rating that was later withdrawn, so none was held on 2026-10-01. I did not count cases where a later action restored the rating (E1115, E1158, E1303) or where another currency basis was still rated.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1002", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1254", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R6 rdf+ontology run 5 graded by code

35 entities. Each had an issuer rating that ended in a withdrawal (WD) action with no later rating action. See the JSON for the list.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R5 csv+ontology run 1 graded by code

35 entities, listed in the JSON. Each has a withdrawal as its latest action. E1158, E1115 and E1303 are not included because later actions re-established a rating.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

❌ R5 csv+ontology run 2 graded by code

36 entities lost their issuer rating through withdrawal.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1158", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

Why: entities: expected ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320'], got ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1158', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320']

✅ R5 csv+ontology run 3 graded by code

35 entities, listed in the JSON (RATINGS record IDs). Their latest LTIDR action is a withdrawal.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1124", "E1032", "E1063", "E1084", "E1233", "E1225", "E1206", "E1218", "E1001", "E1140", "E1320", "E1308", "E1277", "E1219", "E1138", "E1007", "E1062", "E1155", "E1159", "E1021", "E1172", "E1057", "E1121", "E1048", "E1076", "E1166", "E1200", "E1041", "E1316", "E1253", "E1244", "E1107", "E1234", "E1205"]}

✅ R5 csv+ontology run 4 graded by code

35 entities had a rating that was later withdrawn and held no other rating on 2026-10-01 (listed in the JSON). Entities with an LC rating still active, such as E1279 and E1106, are not included.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320", "E1159"]}

✅ R5 csv+ontology run 5 graded by code

35 entities. Each has a withdrawal (WD) as its latest action on every basis and was not re-rated later.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R4 csv+markdown run 1 graded by code

The list is in the JSON. These are the entities whose last issuer rating action before 2026-10-01 was a withdrawal.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1124", "E1032", "E1063", "E1218", "E1076", "E1084", "E1234", "E1233", "E1225", "E1206", "E1121", "E1007", "E1172", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1200", "E1205", "E1219", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320", "E1138", "E1140", "E1107", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1041", "E1021", "E1001"]}

✅ R4 csv+markdown run 2 graded by code

35 entities. All were rated at some point and have since been fully withdrawn.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1124", "E1032", "E1063", "E1084", "E1233", "E1218", "E1225", "E1140", "E1138", "E1320", "E1277", "E1219", "E1316", "E1021", "E1155", "E1308", "E1001", "E1007", "E1206", "E1205", "E1107", "E1121", "E1234", "E1048", "E1244", "E1253", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1041", "E1057", "E1062", "E1076"]}

✅ R4 csv+markdown run 3 graded by code

35 entities, listed in the JSON. Each held a long-term issuer rating that was later withdrawn, with no later action.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R4 csv+markdown run 4 graded by code

35 entities. Each had a rating and then a withdrawal as its latest action. The list is in the JSON block.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R4 csv+markdown run 5 graded by code

35 entities; the list is in the JSON. All had an LTIDR withdrawn (WD) before 1 Oct 2026 with no FC or LC rating left.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

❌ R3 csv+padding run 1 graded by code

36 entities had a rating that was later withdrawn with no later rating action (listed in the JSON).

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1279", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

Why: entities: expected ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320'], got ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1279', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320']

❌ R3 csv+padding run 2 graded by code

36 entities, listed in the JSON. All had a rating and then a WD action on or before 2026-10-01. E1106 is excluded because only its local-currency rating was withdrawn (A1230). E1115, E1158 and E1303 are excluded because of the post-withdrawal anomaly noted under Q9.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1279", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

Why: entities: expected ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320'], got ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1279', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320']

✅ R3 csv+padding run 3 graded by code

35 entities; the list is in the JSON. All are entities whose last issuer-rating action by 2026-10-01 was a withdrawal.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1124", "E1032", "E1063", "E1218", "E1084", "E1233", "E1225", "E1206", "E1001", "E1308", "E1140", "E1138", "E1320", "E1277", "E1219", "E1121", "E1244", "E1007", "E1062", "E1076", "E1021", "E1155", "E1107", "E1166", "E1200", "E1172", "E1159", "E1234", "E1205", "E1253", "E1057", "E1048", "E1316", "E1041"]}

❌ R3 csv+padding run 4 graded by code

36 entities, listed in the JSON block. E07 plus 35 others have a WD as their latest action before 2026-10-01.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1279", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

Why: entities: expected ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320'], got ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1279', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320']

❌ R3 csv+padding run 5 graded by code

36 entities, all of which were withdrawn (WD) before 2026-10-01 (list in the JSON).

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1279", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

Why: entities: expected ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320'], got ['E07', 'E1001', 'E1007', 'E1021', 'E1032', 'E1041', 'E1048', 'E1057', 'E1062', 'E1063', 'E1076', 'E1084', 'E1107', 'E1121', 'E1124', 'E1138', 'E1140', 'E1155', 'E1159', 'E1166', 'E1172', 'E1200', 'E1205', 'E1206', 'E1218', 'E1219', 'E1225', 'E1233', 'E1234', 'E1244', 'E1253', 'E1277', 'E1279', 'E1308', 'E1316', 'E1320']

✅ R10 executed run 1 graded by code

35 entities had an issuer rating that was later withdrawn, with no rating still open on 1 Oct 2026 (listed in the JSON). E1106, E1279 and E1303 are excluded because they still hold or regained a rating.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R10 executed run 2 graded by code

35 entities. Each has an open WD record and no other open issuer rating (E1279 and E1106 keep an open FC or LC rating, so they are excluded). The full list is in the JSON.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R10 executed run 3 graded by code

35 entities have an open WD record, listed in the JSON. E1279 and E1106 still hold a rating in one currency basis, so they are excluded.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R10 executed run 4 graded by code

35 entities have a WD as their latest issuer rating (listed in the JSON). Entities re-rated after a withdrawal, such as E1115 and E1303, are excluded.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R10 executed run 5 graded by code

35 entities, all with an open WD record and no other open issuer rating. They are listed in the JSON below.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R7 csv+neutral run 1 graded by code

Thirty-five entities, listed in the JSON, were rated at some point but have no issuer rating on 2026-10-01. In every case the latest action is a withdrawal. E1106 and E1279 are not on the list because a foreign-currency or local-currency rating remains.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R7 csv+neutral run 2 graded by code

Thirty-five entities, listed in the JSON, whose latest action on every issuer rating is a withdrawal. E1279 and E1106 are not included because each still holds a rating on the other currency basis.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1124", "E1032", "E1063", "E1218", "E1084", "E1233", "E1206", "E1225", "E1308", "E1140", "E1021", "E1001", "E1277", "E1138", "E1320", "E1219", "E1316", "E1244", "E1107", "E1234", "E1205", "E1007", "E1159", "E1121", "E1076", "E1048", "E1062", "E1057", "E1200", "E1155", "E1041", "E1166", "E1172", "E1253"]}

✅ R7 csv+neutral run 3 graded by code

35 entities, listed in the JSON. Each had a rating and its latest action is a withdrawal.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1124", "E1032", "E1063", "E1218", "E1084", "E1233", "E1225", "E1206", "E1308", "E1140", "E1320", "E1159", "E1277", "E1219", "E1244", "E1107", "E1234", "E1205", "E1007", "E1021", "E1076", "E1121", "E1062", "E1155", "E1172", "E1138", "E1166", "E1200", "E1001", "E1253", "E1316", "E1041", "E1057", "E1048"]}

✅ R7 csv+neutral run 4 graded by code

35 entities had an issuer rating that was later withdrawn (listed in the JSON). I did not count E1279 or E1106, because each still has an LC or FC rating on the other basis.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R7 csv+neutral run 5 graded by code

35 entities had a rating that was later withdrawn, with no later rated action (E07 plus 34 others, listed in the JSON).

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1124", "E1032", "E1063", "E1218", "E1084", "E1233", "E1225", "E1206", "E1140", "E1001", "E1138", "E1320", "E1277", "E1219", "E1316", "E1007", "E1021", "E1062", "E1057", "E1308", "E1121", "E1076", "E1107", "E1234", "E1205", "E1244", "E1253", "E1155", "E1048", "E1041", "E1159", "E1172", "E1200", "E1166"]}

✅ R8 csv+axioms run 1 graded by code

35 entities, listed in the JSON. Each had an issuer rating that was later withdrawn (WD) and not reinstated by 2026-10-01.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1002", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1254", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R8 csv+axioms run 2 graded by code

35 rated records had an issuer rating that was later withdrawn and not reinstated (list in the JSON).

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1002", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1254", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R8 csv+axioms run 3 graded by code

35 entities. They had an issuer rating that was later withdrawn and not reinstated (list in the JSON).

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R8 csv+axioms run 4 graded by code

The 35 entities in the JSON were rated at some point but ended in withdrawal (the WD actions, e.g. A19, A1002, A1013, A1046). E1001, E1253 and E1138 appear under their RATINGS IDs, although the withdrawals are on E1002, E1254 and E1138 respectively.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R8 csv+axioms run 5 graded by code

Thirty-five entities, listed in the JSON, were rated but had every issuer-rating series withdrawn by 1 October 2026 (WD actions such as A19).

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R9 csv+axioms+markdown run 1 graded by code

Thirty-five entities, listed in the JSON, were rated at some point but had no issuer rating on 2026-10-01, because a withdrawal was their latest action.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R9 csv+axioms+markdown run 2 graded by code

35 entities. Each has a withdrawal as its last action on every basis and no later rating.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R9 csv+axioms+markdown run 3 graded by code

35 entities; the IDs are in the JSON. Examples are E07 (A19) and E1001 (A1002, via E1002).

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R9 csv+axioms+markdown run 4 graded by code

35 entities, listed in the JSON, whose latest action on their foreign-currency rating is a withdrawal.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}

✅ R9 csv+axioms+markdown run 5 graded by code

35 entities. E07 and 34 E1xxx entities had every issuer rating withdrawn before 2026-10-01 and no later re-rating. They are listed in the JSON.

JSON: {"entities": ["E07", "E1001", "E1007", "E1021", "E1032", "E1041", "E1048", "E1057", "E1062", "E1063", "E1076", "E1084", "E1107", "E1121", "E1124", "E1138", "E1140", "E1155", "E1159", "E1166", "E1172", "E1200", "E1205", "E1206", "E1218", "E1219", "E1225", "E1233", "E1234", "E1244", "E1253", "E1277", "E1308", "E1316", "E1320"]}